top of page

Three Months In, and They're Not Cutting It. Whose Responsibility Is That?

6 days ago
6 min read

Probation periods, performance management and the uncomfortable conversation nobody particularly wants to have.


I recently had a conversation with a client who asked for some professional advice about a chef who wasn't quite making the grade.

Three months into the role, concerns were starting to build. The speed wasn't there, preparation wasn't consistent, standards were slipping and the overall performance wasn't where the business needed it to be.

The question was straightforward:

How do we demonstrate that this chef hasn't passed probation, and what do we need to have in place to support that decision?


It's a fair question, and one I think more hospitality businesses should be asking themselves.

Because here's the thing: if someone has been in your kitchen for three months and isn't performing, is that entirely down to the individual, or have we looked closely enough at what we've done to help them succeed?

Let's be honest, kitchens aren't always the best environments for structured development-or training. We're busy, service is relentless, someone calls in sick, deliveries arrive late and suddenly the training plan has disappeared somewhere between the walk-in fridge and the pot wash. Eye roll emoji.

But probation shouldn't be a three-month waiting game where we cross our fingers and hope someone improves.


1. Have we actually monitored their progress?

A probation period needs structure.

If we're going to tell someone they haven't met expectations, we need to be able to demonstrate what those expectations were in the first place.

Have we:

  • Set clear expectations from day one? With a plan or programme?

  • Explained the standards, responsibilities and pace required?

  • Held regular progress reviews? 1 week, 1 month, 2 month with homework, 3 month sign off as a basic.

  • Recorded feedback and areas requiring improvement?

  • Given the chef an opportunity to respond and demonstrate progress?

Simply saying someone isn't fast enough, isn't organised or isn't quite right isn't particularly helpful.

What does that actually mean?

Are they taking too long to complete preparation? Are they struggling to organise their section? Is food quality inconsistent? Are they failing to communicate with the wider brigade?

Be specific. Be consistent. Most importantly, keep a record.

A chef that hasn't prepped quick enough, is one thing, but is it after a 2 day closure? Plus service, or a day after being a chef short, the variables can be endless.

So having a strong foundation, setting your stall clearly leaves no margin for error, zero margin something those in hospitality SHOULD understand by now....


2. What training and support have we actually provided?

This is where management needs to take some responsibility.

We cannot expect someone to walk into a new kitchen, understand every system, learn every menu, absorb the culture and deliver at the required level without some guidance.

What training was provided?

Was there an induction? Were recipes, specifications and preparation standards explained? Did someone demonstrate the expected methods and timings?

(I dont like it, but - is there a WhatApp group, where food videos or secs are shared?)

Have we given them the tools to succeed, or have we simply handed them a chef's jacket and pointed towards the fryer?

A structured training plan doesn't need to be complicated. It needs to be relevant, achievable and monitored.

If organisation is an issue, work on organisation. If preparation times are inconsistent, establish realistic targets and monitor them.

Training isn't just showing someone something once and assuming they've mastered it.


3. Are we setting measurable targets?

One of the biggest mistakes I see is feedback that is too vague.

"You're too slow."

"Your section needs to be better organised."

"Your prep isn't where it should be."

All valid concerns perhaps, but what does the individual actually need to do differently?

Set tasks with realistic timeframes.

If a section requires a particular preparation list to be completed before service, establish what needs doing, the expected completion time and the quality standard.

Monitor how effectively that work is delivered.

Are they completing preparation on time? Is the quality consistent? Are they working cleanly and efficiently? Are they anticipating service requirements rather than constantly reacting?

And importantly, who is monitoring this?

It shouldn't always fall on the Executive Chef.

The Head Chef, Sous Chef and relevant section leaders should all have visibility of performance. A chef's development is a team responsibility, not an occasional conversation with the most senior person in the building.


4. Have we given feedback before the deadline?

This is probably the most important point.

If someone's probation ends in three months, don't wait until week twelve to tell them there are problems. What would that solve?!

That isn't managing performance; that's delivering a surprise.

Feedback needs to happen throughout the probation period, with clear opportunities to improve, such as timing for example, get faster isnt an answer, if its service, mains need to be when called on the pass in 12 minutes for example, if its prep, then i expect 50 chicken breasts battened and pane'd within 25 minutes, boundaries and expectations, but als the demonstration that those timings can be professionally executed, not just said.

If concerns arise in week four, address them in week four.

If progress is needed by week eight, make that clear and agree what success looks like.

Give the individual a fair opportunity to respond, ask questions and demonstrate improvement.

By the time the final probation review arrives, there should be no major surprises.

They should understand where they stand, what has improved and what still needs attention.

One important point for employers: probation isn't a substitute for a fair employment process. Check the contract, applicable employment rights and your HR advice before making a decision. Keep the process consistent and properly documented.


5. How do we deliver the message?

Nobody particularly enjoys telling someone they haven't passed probation.

For the chef, it can feel like a personal failure. For the business, it can mean starting the recruitment process all over again.

But the conversation needs to be honest, professional and respectful.

Avoid making it personal. Focus on the role, the expectations and the evidence.

Explain:

  • Where performance has fallen short.

  • What feedback and support have already been provided.

  • What opportunities were given to improve.

  • Why the required standard hasn't been achieved.

  • What happens next.

Where appropriate, offer constructive advice and coaching that the individual can take forward.

Not every chef who struggles in one environment is a bad chef.

Sometimes it's the wrong kitchen, the wrong pace, the wrong management style or simply the wrong fit.

That doesn't mean lowering standards. It means understanding where someone might perform better.


6. Is there a better environment for them?

This is where I think businesses and recruiters could work together more effectively.

A chef who struggles in a high-volume, demanding restaurant environment might thrive somewhere with a different operating model.

Perhaps a more casual venue, a smaller brigade or a business with a different service style.

Perhaps they need to develop their organisational skills before stepping into another demanding Head Chef position.

Could they benefit from a sideways move? A different level of responsibility? A kitchen where they can rebuild confidence, improve consistency and develop their technical ability?

Not every career needs to be a straight line upwards.

Sometimes taking a step sideways is the best way to move forward.

Of course, this isn't about passing a problem from one employer to another. It's about honest conversations, realistic expectations and finding the right environment for the individual and the business.


7. So, whose responsibility is it?

Ultimately, probation is a two-way process.

The employer has a responsibility to communicate those expectations, provide appropriate training, monitor progress and address concerns in a timely manner.

The chef has a responsibility to learn, adapt, listen to feedback and deliver the standards expected of them.

Neither side should be left guessing.

If the individual isn't right for the role, that's unfortunate, but it happens. Getting the decision right, communicating it properly and treating people with respect is what matters.

And for operators, here's my advice: don't leave probation reviews until the last minute.

Build them into your management routine. Give your Head Chefs and Sous Chefs responsibility for development. Set measurable targets. Record progress. Have the difficult conversations early.

1 minute management coaching

daily is far more constructive and supportive than a toxic scream in week 11 for being "crap."

Because replacing a chef is expensive, disruptive and time-consuming. Developing the right person is almost always worth the effort.

And if, after all the support, training and feedback, it still isn't working, at least you know you've given the individual a fair opportunity.

....AND, in all of this, it also hugely depends on the dialogue, if as employer, you have moved a CDP from breakfasts shift as the job was offered, 6 weeks later you want them on the pass 4 nights a week too, but haven't changed contract or discussed plans effectively, then we have to really take a look at what we want as business, and team rather than blame a poorly performed employee.


At The Chef Hub, I believe recruitment is about more than finding someone to fill a vacancy. It's about finding the right person, supporting the appointment and helping both sides build something that lasts.


Sometimes the best recruitment advice comes three months after the placement, not on day one. But before then, I do have a training structure you could lean on, listen to your team, watch wherever possible, have the support to help your team, the employee and your investment for the future


How do you manage probation in your kitchen? Is it a structured development process, or does it sometimes become a box-ticking exercise when the deadline approaches? Did I do something you would not? How would you handle it?


I'd be interested to hear how other operators approach it.


Tony Lewis

Founder | The Chef Hub

 
 
 

Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.
bottom of page